The history of the Pioneer Memorial Gardens Cemetery spans more than a century. In the early 19th century, John B. Warren received the land where the cemetery currently sits as part of a crown grant. In 1847, he donated the 115’ frontage and 122’ deep property on “Protestant Hill” to the Wesleyan Methodist Church for a church and cemetery. The Pioneer Cemetery on Oshawa’s Bond Street became the churchyard of the Methodist Church. It should be noted that prior to this date, records indicate that the land had been previously used as a burial ground. In fact, the earliest burial recorded is that of Sabine Dearborn, wife of Samuel Dearborn, in 1830.
This cemetery contained burials of many well-to-do and dedicated church members. The family plots were separated from the others by various means; wrought iron fences, decorative posts with ornamental tops connected by chains, bars or stone borders. An array of wild pink roses and purple lilacs were also plentiful.
The Methodists had the oldest congregation in the Township. Between 1867 and 1868, a new Methodist Church was built on Simcoe Street and was ready for service in 1868. The old church building was sold and then removed, and the basement excavation was filled in. To ensure that no animals pasturing on the public road could enter, a high wooden picket fence with a protective gate was built across the front of the property.
In the early 1900s the high wooden picket fence was removed as well at the protective gate. A modern wire fence then enclosed the property. A couple by the name of Mr. And Mrs. Richard Taylor bought the south-east portion of the front of the property that had been for sale. Their house was erected and their children and grandchildren were members of the Simcoe Street Church. It appears that the unsold portion of the property was still used for burials, the last being that of Barbara Hurd in 1906.
In 1945, due to the deplorable state of the cemetery, the Board of the Simcoe Street United Church decided the property should be cleaned up, and that a plan be adopted that would assure its preservation for years to come. A committee was headed by George Ansley who decided that the neglected cemetery would be transformed into a Memorial Garden. Many of the families removed the remains of relatives to Union Cemetery leaving the old graveyard practically empty. However, many of the tombstones were left behind marking the graves of pioneers. These were lifted, cleaned and eventually arranged on cement pillars in a cairn in the centre of the property.
Today the area is fenced and owned and maintained by the City. A complete listing of the names that appear in the cairn can be found in the archival collection of the Oshawa Museum, and at the Durham Chapter of the Ontario Genealogical Society.